Showing posts with label PC. Show all posts
Showing posts with label PC. Show all posts

Tuesday, July 17, 2012

Review: From Dust (PC)


From Dust is an innovative, artistic, and quite fun game wherein you play as some sort of protector/spirit/glowy thingy guiding a small tribe around dangerous environments and altering the landscape to protect their villages and open up paths for them to travel. It's fairly short at around 4 hours to complete both story and challenge modes, but quite fun for all that.

You interact with the tribesmen only when ordering them to build a new village, fetch something, or go to the level exit, spending most of the game interacting with the environment by picking up blobs of sand, water, or lava and dropping it somewhere else. You can use this to divert the flow of water or lava, build new paths or islands, or goof off. You also get certain special powers for certain levels, and can move around exploding, burning, or leaking trees to help you in your goals. The gameplay is a ton of fun, and the physics for the deformable terrain and various liquids is pretty good. Combined with the nice visuals it can be a lot of fun to just play around with for a while. It makes a pretty fun (and more literal than normal) sandbox, though without any specific goals in mind it gets boring after an hour or two of messing around.

The AI for the tribesmen is pretty horrible though, since they're awfully picky about how steep a slope or how high a step they're willing to go across, and have overall terrible pathfinding. This is especially bad since the only control you have over where they go is to either tell them to go to one of the few  key points on the map, or to cancel the command and let them wander back to their village. You can't even specify which village you want them to come from when ordering them out, though they'll usually come from the closest. Also annoying is that when a village is destroyed a group will always head towards it to rebuild, even if there is no possible path to get there and the site of the former village is still completely submerged. Annoying, but as long as you have at least one village standing you have effectively unlimited tribesmen, so the only real loss is having to listen to the stuck group beg for help until you "accidentally" drop a blob of lava on their heads.
Despite the problematic AI From Dust is still an excellent game and well worth getting for a couple afternoons worth of fun.





...Or rather, that's what I would say if it had been ported to PC by someone halfway competent. There's a 30FPS cap on, no graphics options other than resolution and windowed/fullscreen (no anti-aliasing unless you force it through your graphics card settings), and frequent performance drops to 15-20 FPS even on a relatively high-end (My computer is far above average, but exactly top of the line) machine.

Mouse controls are terribly over-sensitive such that even with sensitivity turned down all the way the pointer goes flying if you give it a slight nudge, and it treats the mouse like a joystick so you have to return the mouse to it's starting position to keep the pointer still. The camera controls could be better too. You can rotate left or right at will, but zooming in and out and changing the vertical angle are tied together, and sometimes the vertical angle just doesn't let you see what you need to.

And then there's the level-specific bugs. For some reason, the countdown timers and water physics are horribly off on the PC version, which for the most part isn't that bad. But there's one level halfway through the story mode that becomes nearly unplayable because the high-tide/low-tide rhythm ends up as high-tide/high-tide, and you can only win by incredibly good timing and a huge amount a luck, meaning you'd better like watching the (thankfully short) cutscene at the start of the level, since you'll be seeing quite a bit of it.

The terrible mouse controls and the iffy AI also mean that the challenge mode, which requires very fast work to win ends up a good bit harder since you have the extra challenge of fighting against crappy controls, which made the most time-sensitive of the challenges more frustrating than fun.

Overall I did enjoy the game quite a bit, despite it's flaws, though since it's a puzzle game I don't see a whole lot of replay value in it. I'm glad it was on sale for $3.74 though, because as terrible a port as it is I'd be very disappointed if I had paid more than $5 for it.

So, the verdict is: get the (theoretically better) console version, or get it on sale.


Or maybe they can patch the PC version so it bloody works.